Dàjiā jiāngxìn-jiāngyí de kàn zhe nàge mòshēngrén.
Everyone looked at the stranger with mixed belief and doubt.
Tips
history
From Li Hua's Tang-dynasty elegy 《吊古战场文》: 人或有言,将信将疑, mourners half-believe, half-doubt tales of the ancient battlefield. The 将…将… pattern means 'now... now...' (simultaneously both).
grammar
The 将…将… construction here is a classical parallelism equivalent to 又…又…, 'both believing and doubting.' This is not the modern 将 meaning 'will / in the future.'